The Golden Goat Awards, or saignée’s top 2000 wines of 2010 countdown

It’s awards season in the wine world!

Of all the things about modern day wine writing i deplore (read David Lillie’s excellent Muscadet piece in the latest Art of Eating for everything right about modern day writing), like tasting notes that delete “pleasure” or scores that delete almost everything, there is nothing that quite irks me as much as a ranked lists. the great vins de garde of the world side by side the great vins de soif with everything in between is a feat of mental gymnastics that very few people any good, except for magazines, collectors who don’t actually, you know, drink wine, and retailers and the very few “winners.”

Of course i realize that by saying the above i’m treading into some dreadfully clichéd territory. We’ve been down this path before, someone will agree, someone won’t agree, and very little will change. shelf talkers will still exist, as well as top 100 lists and little gold stickers to affix to said “top 100” bottles.

So this year saignée has decided to compile a list of wines that i enjoyed during the past year. i’m not going to bother to rank them in any sort of order. Instead, when in the course of any day i remember a wine that made me smile, i’m going to go ahead and write it down. i’ll tell you where i was when i drank it, what about it particularly made me happy, and if i know anything beyond that, i’ll add that it. i don’t how often i’ll be adding to this countdown, and there won’t actually be 2000 wines on the list, but whatever. And, if you would like, please put down wines that made you smile in the comments, or email them to me, and i’ll put them up for everyone to read.


Ten Ten, Hank Beckmeyer’s newest goat, is the official mascot of saignée’s top 2000 wines of 2010. All wineries mentioned will receive a “golden goat” as a prize (note: prize may not actually exist).

Guy Bossard 2009 Muscadet “Cuvee Classique”: i drank this bottle on the porch of my great uncle’s house in Montreat North Carolina. It was early fall, still warm enough to be enjoyable, and certainly not hot enough to qualify for southern heat. I was there for a family reunion n my great grandmother’s side. The last family reunion we had was some 17 years ago, and of course many of the people had passed on, and many more had been born. Bossard, like may of the great Muscadet producers, makes the perfect antidote for many of the heavy handed wines that are just now going out of style. This is the type wine where what isn’t there is just as important as what is there. No heaviness, no extraction, no tricks, no pretense (unlike this sentence). Just pure beautiful wine.

Arrianna Occhipinti 2007 Il Frappato: Speaking of pure, beautiful wines is there anyone making wines quite as lovely as these? i was sitting there at a lunch with some friends and we were drinking Southern Italian wines when this was poured. And repoured, and then emptied, with a great deal of sadness, as this was the best bottle i’d yet tasted. If you ever want someone to get what a “natural” wine is, just tell them to get a bottle of this and save your breath. Or better yet sit and drink a bottle with them. i asked Joe Dressner how she did it and his reply was “nothing complicated.” Truer words have never been spoken.

To be continued…

(i have to write 999 more of these at this pace)

~ by Cory Cartwright on November 18, 2010.

4 Responses to “The Golden Goat Awards, or saignée’s top 2000 wines of 2010 countdown”

  1. Cory

    Thanks for the goat photos, that has to be the cutest goat I have ever seen..

  2. hell yeah…bad wines always taste better when it comes with a” great “story…it sells better when it comes with a storry…drrunk….Arrianna!!! RRRRR!!!
    Please more stories and less wine…
    I hope Chateau Mytho and Domaine Laflute will be appearing on your next favorites.
    Luccio del Mambo
    L’homme qui dit de la merde plus vite que son ombre mais ne boit pas du caca.
    Cheers….

  3. Great post Cory. You have the perfect mascot in Top Ten.

    I’m not sure I fully understand it, but I think Luc deserves a golden goat prize for such an awesome comment.

  4. Loving the Occhipinti wines Cory …… Cos also…their 2009 Frappato is a ripper….standard & the 2008 Phytos also.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: